Small Changes Make a Huge Difference

I am in the process of a new room design that recently had some new tweaks! When comparing the two designs, there are only a few small changes, but the end result is very different. I was amazed at the power of fabric in a room's design! There will be more info on the details of this room later, but for now- which is your favorite and why?

Masculine Chic Design #1

or...

Masculine Chic Design #2

If you were the client, which would you choose and why?